The most honest thing you can say about Kadyn Proctor is that he exists in a state of simultaneous elite potential and genuine uncertainty, and that tension will define his draft evaluation from now until his name is called. At 6'7", 366 to 368 pounds, he is one of the most physically imposing offensive tackle prospects in recent draft history. He is also a player whose technical development has not kept pace with his physical growth — creating the high-risk, high-reward profile that NFL teams spend entire pre-draft processes arguing about.
Proctor committed to Iowa out of Southeast Polk High School in Iowa as a five-star recruit, then transferred to Alabama — where he started two full seasons at left tackle against elite SEC competition. His production was significant (one of the better PFF grade trajectories in the SEC) but his pass-protection statistics — including 22 quarterback pressures and 2 sacks allowed in 2025 — tell a complicated story about a player whose physical gifts aren't yet being maximized by his technique.
STRENGTHS
The physical profile is the beginning and end of the bull case for Proctor. At 6'7", 368 pounds, he is — as one evaluation source described him — a "MAMMOTH," and watching his run-blocking film confirms that the description is earned. When he fires off the ball on run plays with urgency and proper pad level, he displaces SEC defensive linemen in ways that simply cannot be taught or manufactured. In goal-line situations against Alabama's opponents — including Georgia — he was generating push that moved legitimate NFL prospects backward. That's physical dominance at the highest available level.
His athleticism is the trait that makes the elite offensive line development programs most excited. For a man of his extraordinary size, his lateral movement in pass protection is surprising — the kick-slide is functional, his ability to redirect in space is better than his measurements would suggest, and his second-level blocking in the run game shows genuine athleticism in climbing to linebackers. The GSLING comparison analysis (which directly evaluated Proctor against Kelvin Banks Jr. of Texas) credited Proctor with wins in all six evaluated categories including athleticism.
The run game film is legitimately special. Against LSU and Georgia in the SEC, his combination blocks, double teams, and individual drive blocks were among the most dominant interior OL reps produced in this draft class.
CONCERNS
The pass protection is the entire conversation against drafting Proctor in the top-15. Twenty-two quarterback pressures and 2 sacks allowed is a concerning number for a projected first-round blind-side starter, and the film confirms that the numbers reflect real technical limitations rather than statistical noise. His pad level inconsistency — rising out of his stance after initial kick-slide contact — creates the exploitable leverage window that NFL speed-to-power rushers will attack. The Georgia and Oklahoma game film shows this pattern.
Scout 2's assessment is more skeptical than Scout 1's: "stiff hips and plodding kickslide scream RT/guard bust if pass pro doesn't evolve." That's a harsh take, but the concern is documented. Scout 1 counters with the developmental arc argument — that the Trent Brown trajectory (physically dominant player who refined technique in the NFL) is the appropriate model.
SCOUT GRADES
This is another significant scout split. Scout 1 graded Proctor at 78/100, projecting Round 1, picks 20 to 35 — a back-half-of-the-first-round assessment that discounts the pass protection. Scout 2 graded him at 87/100 with a projection of Round 1, picks 20 to 32 — a similar range but a dramatically higher talent grade. The difference: Scout 2 believes the physical tools are so elite that the technical development is nearly guaranteed; Scout 1 is more agnostic.
Both evaluators agree on the range. The disagreement is on ceiling and confidence level.
PROJECTION
Proctor is a pick 20-to-35 prospect in the current evaluation environment. Teams with elite offensive line development programs and patient front offices will be most aggressive. If he lands in San Francisco (Shanahan's staff), Detroit, or with a team that has historically developed massive offensive tackles into elite players, the ceiling is genuine franchise left tackle. If he lands in a system without strong line coaching, the guard/RT transition becomes the conversation by Year 2.
Draft him in the first round knowing that you're paying for the ceiling. The floor is a very good starting tackle at right or left. The ceiling is elite.
View Kadyn Proctor's full player profile, measurables, and scouting breakdown →
🎬 All-22 Film Analysis Update
*Updated after All-22 film review by Scout1 and Scout2.*
Film Score: 82.5/100 (→ No change from base score of 82.5)
Composite Score: 84
Scout1 Assessment Kadyn Proctor is a physically freakish left tackle — 6'7", 368 lbs of rare mass and movement who gives NFL line coaches something they can't manufacture in a weight room. He's a monster in the run game, a powerful anchor in pass protection against power rushers, and the kind of trait-first prospect that teams with elite offensive line development programs will covet. The case against him is real, though: he's inconsistent in pass protection, particularly against speed-to-power conversions and te...
Scout2 Assessment Proctor's a top-40 mauler with Day 1 power, but pass pro athleticism caps him outside top-15. Contrarian fade on LT1 hype — target late R1 for run-heavy fits.
*Film analysis is based on All-22 footage reviewed independently by two scouts. Scores reflect on-field evidence and may differ from pre-film model projections.*